r/canadaguns • u/AutoModerator • 2d ago

Recurring Canadaguns Politics and Debate Thread

Please post all your Gun Politics or Ban-related ideas, questions, initiatives, comments, suggestions, news articles, and recommendations in this thread. This thread recurs every 14 days.

First and foremost, this is a Canadian Gun subreddit, so keep it at least decently related to both of those things.

This thread is not for general politics, there are plenty other subs that are meant for that. Off-topic threads may be removed, especially if they are leading to personal attacks, flame wars, etc.

To prevent the main sub being flooded with dozens of similar threads, text posts complaining about/asking about/chatting about gun politics will be sent here.

We understand that politics is a touchy subject, and at times things can get heated. A reminder of the subreddit rules, when commenting, where subreddit users are expected to abide.

Keep this Canadian gun politics related and polite. Off-topic stuff, flame wars, negative generalizations against groups, personal attacks and gate-keeping will be removed. Please flag any comments to bring to the attention of mods otherwise exercise your upvoting and downvoting ability.

16 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

85 comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/boozefiend3000 2d ago

I am not a proud Canadian 

22

u/Beneficial-Ride-4475 1d ago edited 1d ago

I got a kick how infuriated people were in the main Canada sub when I said I hadn't called myself Canadian in years, and I didn't feel like I fit in here. Like yeah, I don't feel welcome. When my interest in firearms apparently makes me a latent criminal in the eyes of government and certain Canadians.

Yes, I don't feel Canadian, and haven't for some time.

6

u/InitialAd4125 1d ago

Why would anyone want to be associated with this nation or most nations in fact is amusing considering besides a small handful of nations how many can honestly be considered net positives to the world and there citizens? Certainly not Canada that's for sure based on our history and the current way the state treats us the peons.

6

u/Beneficial-Ride-4475 1d ago edited 1d ago

Why would anyone want to be associated with this nation or most nations in fact

Keep in mind, I went to university for humanities, of which I only learned the basics, but it was informative. And that education certainly informs my take on this.

I'm a bit of an anarchist, and certainly anti-nationalist, so I really don't understand or support concepts like chauvinism, or exceptionalism. But I do grasp why people want a place to belong. Truthfully, when I see all this Canadian patriotism going around, I grasp why it's happening, but the fact is, this new fervor is actively pushing away the out groups (subcultures, etc) even further.

This is what happens when a society starts leaning to heavily in one direction, in this case, societal collectivism or nationalism. Canada is headed in that direction, just like Japan. Japanese society places a high value on group harmony and social conformity, meaning that behavior disrupting public order or consensus (or in Canada's case, peace and politness) is often discouraged.

Which is fine if you fit in but...

On the other hand, the US leans in the opposite direction, hyper individualism, with, what I judge, to be poor results. (An unpopular take on this sub no doubt).

Society is a balance. Not one thing or the other. When society begins focusing on one thing to the exclusion of others, that's a failure of society.

Our society doesn't like like it's interested in maintaining balance anymore.

2

u/Q-Ball7 In the end, it's taxes all the way down 19h ago

Canada is headed in that direction, just like Japan.

No, it isn't.

Canada's problem is that it's Toronto/Ottawa/Montreal (and Vancouver) vs. the rest of the country. This has been true since about 1867.

The US has checks in its government systems against this. We do not. Witness the results.

I don't share a culture with these people (even the word "Canadian" is manufacturing their consensus), and there's no reason they should be making law for me.

2

u/InitialAd4125 1d ago

"Canada is headed in that direction, just like Japan. Japanese society places a high value on group harmony and social conformity, meaning that behavior disrupting public order or consensus (or in Canada's case, peace and politness) is often discouraged."

Frankly I'm not all that big a fan of Japan America did a shit job rebuilding it. Could have made it like Switzerland but nope they wanted a good little puppet.

"The US leans in the opposite direction, hyper individualism, with, what I judge, to be poor results. (An unpopular on this sub no doubt)."

Eh it's not entirely wrong but that's kind of what they claim not always the reality after all the consider "corporations" people to an absurd degree. Because it's hyper individualisms hard bullshit everyone for themselves for the peons bailouts for the rich and companies.

"Our society doesn't like like it's interested in maintaining balance anymore."

Did it ever though? Like looking at Canada's history it's just a state stomping on certain out groups of people anytime they questioned why things were this way.

3

u/Beneficial-Ride-4475 1d ago

Could have made it like Switzerland but nope they wanted a good little puppet.

Arguably, they've already done that to us. 50% of Canada's economy is owned by Americans according to StatsCan.

Eh it's not entirely wrong but that's kind of what they claim not always the reality after all the consider "corporations" people to an absurd degree.

You can thank Ronald Reagan for that. Guy paved the way for oligarchs.

Because it's hyper individualisms hard bullshit everyone for themselves for the peons bailouts for the rich and companies.

Well, that's just it isn't it? Hyper individualism thrives on peons.

Did it ever though? Like looking at Canada's history it's just a state stomping on certain out groups of people anytime they questioned why things were this way.

Yeah, that's true. It's just that I remember a time where cooperation and understanding were expressed as Canadian values, and actually practiced. But that could be me putting on rose tinted glass and looking through the foggy mirror of time.

3

u/InitialAd4125 1d ago

"You can thank Ronald Reagan for that. Guy paved the way for oligarchs."

Also a big reason why California has worse gun laws then most of America because of the Black Panthers.

"Yeah, that's true. It's just that I remember a time where cooperation and understanding were expressed as Canadian values, and actually practiced. But that could be me putting on rose tinted glass and looking through the foggy mirror of time."

Sadly I think those are rose tinted like what time would you say this was. Certainly not when being gay was illegal. Or certain groups of people were being put into camps so arguably no time before World War 2. And anything before 1969 if you were gay I'd say there was certainly a lack of understanding. And if you're Indigenous well shit man I can't think of a time ever in Canadian history. Like maybe certain communities in Canada had these values but the nation and the nation state? Not so much.

4

u/Beneficial-Ride-4475 1d ago

Also a big reason why California has worse gun laws then most of America because of the Black Panthers.

I can't tell you how many American gun guys melt down when I mention that.

Sadly I think those are rose tinted like what time would you say this was. Certainly not when being gay was illegal. Or certain groups of people were being put into camps so arguably no time before World War 2. And anything before 1969 if you were gay I'd say there was certainly a lack of understanding. And if you're Indigenous well shit man I can't think of a time ever in Canadian history. Like maybe certain communities in Canada had these values but the nation and the nation state? Not so much.

My rose tinted glasses were taking me back to the 2000s (more specifically, 2000-2011) but now I that I think about it, you're right. It was bad back then too.

5

u/InitialAd4125 1d ago

"(more specifically, 2000-2011)"

I don't know that entire time when I think of it I think of the 2008 financial crisis.

3

u/Beneficial-Ride-4475 1d ago edited 1d ago

Maybe it's because of where I lived? Granted, I was only in my late teens in 2008 so...

3

u/InitialAd4125 1d ago

I was four at that point though I just look at things from a historical lens not personal.

→ More replies (0)