Carmel Accuracy

[u/Embarrassed-Gur1769]

R Carmel
88m(96y), bipod in front, bag in rear
Kahles k18i-2 lpvo
1x1 inch squares
5 shots each, except the 2 in the center in the first pic are also from Swiss P.

[u/MostEnergeticSloth]

Has anyone done any identical-ammo accuracy testing with the Makasi and this side by side? Just curious, this is more than acceptable out of an R barrel regardless. Sucks the gun market is what it is right now, but frankly if I had to choose between a decades old state-backed arms manufacturer and a few guys with a CNC in a shop, I'm picking the former.

[u/Embarrassed-Gur1769 → u/MostEnergeticSloth]

Such into exists on CGN.
I’m copy and pasting so format may be horrible.
He shot it at 100 yards with razor G3 1-10. Bipod in front, bag in rear:
Cartridge Description
80% Group (MOA)
90% Group (MOA)
100% Group (MOA)
Federal Premium Gold Medal Sierra MatchKing
223 Rem, 77 Grain, Sierra Matchking BTHP
0.98
1.88
2.11
Sellier & Bellot Tactical Rifle Ammunition
223 Rem, 69 Grain, HPBT
1.00
1.34
2.11
Barnaul
223 Rem, 62 Grain, SPBT, lacquered steel case
2.04
2.44
3.00
Barnaul
223 Rem, 55 Grain, HPBT, lacquered steel case
2.07
2.44
2.70
PMC X-TAC M193
5.56 NATO, 55 Grain, FMJBT
2.28
2.52
3.78
PMC Bronze
223 Rem, 55 Grain, FMJBT
2.52
3.04
3.25
Chinese Surplus M193
5.56 NATO, 55 Grain, FMJBT
2.88
3.01
3.87
Federal American Eagle
5.56 NATO, 55 Grain, FMJ
2.96
3.75
4.44
MFS
223 Rem, 55 Grain, FMJ, zinc plated steel case
3.07
3.74
4.02
Winchester “USA White Box” M193
5.56 NATO, 55 Grain, FMJ
3.14
3.75
5.11
Federal American Eagle
223 Rem, 55 Grain, FMJ
3.44
3.56
5.19
PMC X-TAC M855
5.56 NATO, 62 Grain, Green Tip
4.52
–*
–*
Federal American Eagle
223 Rem, 62 Grain, FMJ BT
4.91
5.02
6.60
Average
2.76
3.04
3.85

[u/MostEnergeticSloth → u/Embarrassed-Gur1769]

So this is all Makasi accuracy data? Unfortunately it looks like literally none of the ammo they used is the same as the stuff you used though

[u/Embarrassed-Gur1769 → u/MostEnergeticSloth]

Yea, my stockpile is older and from before ARs are banned. Idk if you can even find the Swiss P or Geco 556 anymore.

The only one I have from that list is the Norinco m193, but i havent opened tuna can yet

[u/MostEnergeticSloth → u/Embarrassed-Gur1769]

I've still got a few boxes of that nice RUAG AP tucked away... And I'll probably end up passing my Norinco 193 tuna cans down to my kids kids 🤣