r/canadaguns 6d ago

Misc Hadn't Seen This One Yet

This is how we get all guns banned in Canada.

302 Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

View all comments

256

u/AdhesiveCam 6d ago

This kind of behavior is going to lose us all of our guns before too long.

130

u/yuikkiuy bc 6d ago

how many of these people even have a valid license? how many are citizens? can non citizens hold a PAL?

58

u/Whispersfine 6d ago

Non citizens can

118

u/AceArchangel 6d ago

That seems absolutely wack to me

-28

u/Rogan403 6d ago

Why? We license non-citizens to drive so why is it wack to let non-citizens get a firearm license?

32

u/Receedus 6d ago

Why should we issue firearms licenses to foreign nationals?

13

u/Cre_AK47 Name Prohibited by OIC 6d ago

The biggest reason we do it is for Americans who like to hunt in Canada

15

u/Dantheislander 6d ago

You can get a short term import permit no pal needed. But commenter above is off their rocker we don’t issue guns we issue licences to those who meet all criteria and pass testing.

3

u/goodfleance 6d ago

If they meet the same requirements we do and want to come here to hunt or compete, what's the problem?

0

u/Receedus 5d ago

Fair point. I would posit that we should only let countries that have proper crimimal record checks participate.

1

u/Specialist_Chard5231 4d ago

If we can't trust them with a firearm why are we allowing them in at all?

2

u/Receedus 4d ago

Wage suppression of course.

10

u/DimGrows 6d ago

In this particular case, and many like it on social media in recent years, the non-citizens are not following the firearm laws. Add to that, that our courts will give leniency to them because of their immigration status, they should at the very least have to wait until they are citizens IMO. If we can’t enforce the laws because of their immigration status, I think we should remove the privilege.

-3

u/Rogan403 6d ago

Non-citizens don't follow traffic laws all the time too. You don't punish an entire group for the actions of one.

Everyone is equal under the law so the solution isn't restricting firearms licenses from non-citizens but instead just punishing those who break the laws/regulations regarding firearm usage and ownership with the same level of strictness that citizens do.

-5

u/DimGrows 6d ago

Agreed. How do you make the courts actually follow-through on that though? It’s the right answer but in reality the lawyers will literally argue that if they get punished it will hurt their immigration status, and this has proven to be a successful argument for leniency in court.

1

u/Rogan403 6d ago

I don't have an answer. It's hard enough to get the goverment to do something it wants to do nevermind something it has no care to do so I have no idea how to get them to start enforcing laws properly, regardless of immigration status, if that's even possible at all.

But I know 2 wrongs don't make a right.

Plus if the goverment is so reluctant to properly enforce firearm laws on immigrants because it might hurt their status and appear discrimatory then they're DEFINITELY not gonna make a rule restricting firearm licenses to citizens.