r/canadaguns • u/Hmfic_48 • 29d ago

News / Politics / Activism Scarborough resident charged after firing gun during attempted car theft

https://toronto.citynews.ca/2026/08/19/scarborough-resident-charged-firing-gun-vehicle-theft-toronto-police/
107 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

123 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Anonymous_Arthur00 29d ago edited 29d ago

Yes actually it was his fault, he shot to protect his property not his life so its not self defense and the current laws mandate a proportionate response when it comes to protecting your property.

yes i think the current laws suck, yes i own guns and i do believe we should have some form of Castle doctrine in regards to self defence but either leaving your house to confront someone outside and/or firing from your house and damaging a neighbors house with gunfire is not only negligent but reckless and irresponsible.

Actions have Consequences

-1

u/hafetysazard 29d ago

How can you blame a person who was forced to take an action to protect themselves?

5

u/Anonymous_Arthur00 29d ago

Protect themselves?

as per the article he shot at people breaking into his vehicle in his driveway which implies he either left his house to confront them with a gun or shot at them from inside his home.

that's not self defense to me, Regardless I'm not trying to villainize the guy but he still shot at someone, apparently missed and hit another house, at that point he's still a reckless idiot for that until there's any real proof he was in danger and was justified.

Would like to clarify again that i am absolutely for using firearms in self defense and do think the laws around that need to change here.

0

u/hafetysazard 29d ago

If they attacked him after he confronted them, then it still could be. It doesn’t imply carelessness or recklessness. If he fired a shot just to scare them away, different story. However he was already being victimized by thieves, and it isn’t a big stretch to believe he was also under some physical threat; especially when bold thieves these days are known to carry weapons. 

The whole mindset that you, as a victim, have to act perfectly reasonable with all your actions and assumptions, even through an examination afterwards with the benefit of hindsight, when you’re being forced into a unreasonable circumstance by somebody who is behaving unreasonable, has to stop.