r/canadaguns • u/Critical_cheese • May 10 '26

Misc Would you take this trade?

I was at the gun show with a buddy today. He bought an Ithaca 37 in great condition for $450. As we were walking out some guy saw it and said he would trade his savage Arms shotgun auto 5 clone. He said he paid $350 for it. Would you guys make that trade? What are you opinions?

11 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

19

u/KalashnikovParty May 10 '26

No, an Ithaca in good condition is worth around 550-600 depending on the year of production and slam fire capability. I don’t know about the savage but they typically produce firearms available for a lot cheaper 

5

u/Connect_Heat_6136 May 10 '26

I have an ithica 37 featherlite, they are really good in quality of build, I've never had an issue with feeding, firing, extraction or ejection. Regardless of type load I've used. I wouldn't make that trade unless you really want at auto 5 clone or just a semi-auto imo

2

u/epnk420 May 10 '26

Don’t do it

2

u/epnk420 May 10 '26

I regret the one savage I own lol

2

u/SierraRomeoJuliet May 10 '26

Absolutely not

2

u/Strong-Owl-55 May 11 '26

Nope I got my ithica for sale for 600$ mostly because I dont want to sell it