r/canadaguns • u/GhostProtocolGaming • Mar 12 '26

News / Politics / Activism Stand on Guard - Conservative Party of Canada

https://www.conservative.ca/stand-on-guard-2/

The bill makes important changes to Section 34 of the Criminal Code so that force is presumed to be justified if used against an illegal intruder. Conservatives first announced the ‘Stand on Guard’ principle back in August, asking the government to introduce legislation in the fall session.

273 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/penny-acre-01 Mar 12 '26

Does "property" include land? Would this mean someone can shoot me if I accidentally cross their property line?

I suppose the key is in the word "presumed" which doesn't exclude someone for being tried, it just doesn't force everyone to go to court unless the crown choses to press charges? Is that it?

2

u/Visible_Bar_6774 Mar 12 '26

I’m not particularly familiar with the case law, maybe one of the lawyers that frequents the sub will chime in. My understanding is that you’ve got good odds of being acquitted in a home invasion case if they are beyond the threshold of the home, but that this doesn’t extend to the whole property. I think the justification is that once someone passes the threshold they reasonably constitute a threat to the occupants.

1

u/CorsicanMastiffStrip Mar 13 '26

That would be good. We do have to be careful with how it ends up defined as we should by no means be allowing someone to cause injury to someone who made a reasonable mistake and was not threatening. Someone accidentally entering someone's land is not a threat. But a stranger in your home who won't leave absolutely is.

1

u/Visible_Bar_6774 Mar 13 '26

I don’t know, I’ve never mistakenly walked into a strangers home, reasonable to assume a threat. How do you propose someone, in the midst of a home invasion, determines whether the invader is a threat? A stranger in mine will be met with 1oz centre mass.

1

u/CorsicanMastiffStrip Mar 13 '26

That’s why I said “land”, not home.