r/canadaguns • u/SmatheAverage • Jul 21 '26

Feets / Collection / My build Cry Harder Poly

Post image

Never lose hope and make the most of our current circumstances, lads.

458 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

122 comments sorted by

View all comments

42

u/Whispersfine Jul 22 '26

I’ve been downvoted to oblivion for saying makasi is just a w180 game 2.0. Well, here we are, another owner telling us to buy Carmel instead.

How hard it is to believe that a few guys with CNC machines just can’t make good guns. Give me a break.

9

u/GodsGiftToWrenching Jul 22 '26

I feel like the Carmel will be ass too, in the few unboxing videos I've seen this week from the few guys that got them the thing looks absolutely gigantic, like a tactical tuna with 2x4 furniture, also in every video the light catches the bolt nicely and you can see all the super rushed and kinda shitty machining all over the bolt, just like Cringesader, Ruger, and the soviets did

2

u/IcySkyDream Jul 22 '26

My Israeli X95 has those milling marks too.

1

u/GodsGiftToWrenching Jul 22 '26

That is quite a bummer, my Bren 2 doesn't, nor does my savage 10T-SR, you would think if savage can afford to properly finish their rifles then a mil spec manufacturer could too

3

u/IcySkyDream Jul 22 '26

I don’t consider it a negative, TBH. It’s a mil-spec MSR, not a fancy hunting rifle.

1

u/GodsGiftToWrenching Jul 22 '26

I'd comnsider it a negative lol, you're paying how many thousands for somethjng with Cringesader quality? It is a mil spec modern sporting rifle... bit for the civilian market not the front lines, and a savage 10T-SR is about the furthest thing from a fancy hunting rifle, literally the bottom of the barrel most entry level target rifle at 650 bucks, and it comes with a 5R barrel and a finisher better than IWI, I think they can spare a couple min, slow their feed rate, and tumble their bolt carriers before bluing

1

u/IcySkyDream Jul 22 '26

I suppose Colt could also ensure their rifles don’t arrive with factory dings and scrapes, but such is the nature of military-spec firearms.

0

u/GodsGiftToWrenching Jul 22 '26

I will say the 1911 series 70 and SP-1 do not have the machining marks that the carmel appears ro have, I have no experience with new colt

2

u/IcySkyDream Jul 22 '26

Just a matter of customer demand, I think.

The typical LE department ordering duty rifles only cares that they work, so Colt’s QC reflects that.

The series 70 and 89 1911s were always aimed at civilians.

Having said that, my US-made X95 bolt carrier looks cleaner. Both work just fine. 🤷